Page 1 of 4 123 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 61
  1. #1
    Administrator Spit-wad's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Madison, WI
    Posts
    13,236
    Steam ID
    Spit-wad

    Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    Mafia #2 was obviously the better game, but not only because of the setup... the players were more active and more into the game.
    The different roles in Mafia #3, Governor and Amnesiac, were kind of a pain, as they were one-use abilities that occurred after a lynch. I don't plan to use the Governor in the future, but maybe the Amnesiac.

    Both games were heavily in Mafia's favor. Mafia #2 had Blue Mafia eliminated extremely quickly, but Red Mafia was in just about as strong of a position as they could have hoped for near the end. The investigatory roles of the town kicked in and they won via Masonry discussion and lynching, not necessarily the power night roles.

    Mafia #3 was full of town fail. zzqq the Vigilante pretty much carried the town with 3 consecutive kills on Mafia to end the game. TehPinkEmoBunni came extremely close to winning as the Serial Killer. With 4 people left, the last lynch almost went towards either Haxity or sheep, which would have left a 2v1. The SK knew who the Vigilante was, but zzqq would have been taking a 50/50 shot at night to eliminate the SK. If he misfired, the SK would have won. It was actually a pretty good ending to a fairly boring game.


    There have been some complaints about the Town having too many power roles. I disagree. Everyone having a special role of some sort makes the game more fun for everyone involved. Being a useless townsperson is boring. However, determining roles by elimination is tough to beat. Both games had Mafia in a very good position, yet they ended up losing. Next game will have a list of some Town roles that will definitely be in the game, as well as a list of roles which only some will be included.

    Players. I'd like to keep the Mafia #2 crew together instead of shuffling it around too much. 2NE1.DARA will be removed from this group and he was simply not as active as everyone else, slowing down the game (and also contributed almost nothing to day chat). Depending on how many people don't sign up for the next game, the extra slots will be filled by active players from Mafia #3.

    We'll keep running 2 games at a time as long as there are enough players, but for now Mafia #4 will be the "good game" of players that have already proved to be active/have a good understanding of the game. Mafia #5 will be for the rest to show that they can play in the better game next time. Depending on how the games go, Mafia #6 might be started halfway through 4 and 5, consisting of the dead players from both games.

    I'll work on the setup while you guys talk about this.

  2. #2
    Holy Shit asrmatt's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Posts
    7,292
    Steam ID
    asrmatt8

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    we need some pinkemobunni in our game

    get rid of destrolys he kept telling me he was part of the rebecca black cult

    jing: first time i saw my girl
    jing: i mumbled for like an hour
    jing: i couldn't even keep eye contact
    jing: and she was like "can you speak up"
    jing: and then i just fucking left

    jing: i tried eating the girl out but i had no idea what i was doing
    jing: i felt like she faked moans or w/e
    jing: cause i had 0 idea of how to eat a girl out
    jing: i flicked it with my tongue
    jing: but eventually it got kind of repetitive and i had no idea what to do next
    jing: what a fucking horrible story

  3. #3
    Holy Shit Risk's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Montreal
    Posts
    6,279
    Steam ID
    Risk_Player

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    Hi, I would like to add that at first, I tought Mason Leader was a boring role. It actually was a very fun/entertaining role, since in the Mason chat we could talk/share/plan.

    Anyways, I hope Mason leader is a role that stays :)

    I'm now officially addicted to Mafia guys

  4. #4
    Holy Shit asrmatt's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Posts
    7,292
    Steam ID
    asrmatt8

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    also varying degrees of punishment for post-lynch/nighttime talking based on the relative impact it has on the game

    also spit is there another chat site we could use cuz chatzy was terrible

    jing: first time i saw my girl
    jing: i mumbled for like an hour
    jing: i couldn't even keep eye contact
    jing: and she was like "can you speak up"
    jing: and then i just fucking left

    jing: i tried eating the girl out but i had no idea what i was doing
    jing: i felt like she faked moans or w/e
    jing: cause i had 0 idea of how to eat a girl out
    jing: i flicked it with my tongue
    jing: but eventually it got kind of repetitive and i had no idea what to do next
    jing: what a fucking horrible story

  5. #5

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    next game if u lynch me ima kill miggy forreal

  6. #6
    Holy Shit Risk's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Montreal
    Posts
    6,279
    Steam ID
    Risk_Player

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    Ya, Chatzy was prettttttty bad. So much delay t_t

    c.sph, sorry for trying to get you lynched but that was DA WORST DEFENSE ever

  7. #7

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    LOL i was scared ok i had 7 hours of school with no computer

  8. #8
    Holy Shit Risk's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Montreal
    Posts
    6,279
    Steam ID
    Risk_Player

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    I would also like to add that WTFDOTA is the worst mafia player ever

  9. #9

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    Depending on how the games go, Mafia #6 might be started halfway through 4 and 5, consisting of the dead players from both games.
    I'm going to pretend like my contribution made a difference there. :3

    asrmatt (6:10): im tempted to start watching friends again
    TehPinkEmoBunni (6:11): haha I am too
    asrmatt (6:11): can we watch it together.
    and hold hands.
    or instead of holding hands, if that's too awkward
    we can put popcorn inbetween us
    and synchronize when we reach to get some
    and briefly touch
    look into each others eyes
    sense a burning passion
    and the lingering feel of the other's imprint on our hands
    and lick our lips sensually
    then take turns getting popcorn and go back to the show

  10. #10
    I love Love LOVE NADOTA!!
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Posts
    30,460

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    I cant wait to die first every game!!!

  11. #11

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    nah don't worry darksheep will be the first one to die

  12. #12

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    Quote Originally Posted by Risk_Player
    I would also like to add that WTFDOTA is the worst mafia player ever
    ima_sheep(sux)

    PERIOD

  13. #13

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    Quote Originally Posted by Risk_Player
    Ya, Chatzy was prettttttty bad. So much delay t_t

    c.sph, sorry for trying to get you lynched but that was DA WORST DEFENSE ever

    Google Wave -- easy.

  14. #14
    Wicked Sick WoT's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    OC CA
    Posts
    1,080

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    wtfdota was pretty awful... if he had a crucial role we would have been screwed.

    Question for spit: what happened on that first night where only grant was killed?
    Also, who was the original mason member? (not risk)

  15. #15
    Holy Shit Risk's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Montreal
    Posts
    6,279
    Steam ID
    Risk_Player

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    tsumugi was automatically added night #1 by Spit-Wad

  16. #16

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    Quote Originally Posted by zzqq
    Quote Originally Posted by Risk_Player
    I would also like to add that WTFDOTA is the worst mafia player ever
    ima_sheep(sux)

    PERIOD
    Townies really did need their watcher to actually say something. >_>;

    asrmatt (6:10): im tempted to start watching friends again
    TehPinkEmoBunni (6:11): haha I am too
    asrmatt (6:11): can we watch it together.
    and hold hands.
    or instead of holding hands, if that's too awkward
    we can put popcorn inbetween us
    and synchronize when we reach to get some
    and briefly touch
    look into each others eyes
    sense a burning passion
    and the lingering feel of the other's imprint on our hands
    and lick our lips sensually
    then take turns getting popcorn and go back to the show

  17. #17
    M-M-M-Monster Kill
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Posts
    1,555

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    we (red mafia) took out grant on the first night LMAO

  18. #18

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    remove 2ne1.dara from group 2 and add moon

  19. #19
    Wicked Sick WoT's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    OC CA
    Posts
    1,080

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    rofl nice. I'm assuming then blue mafia and dee went for miggy and he got saved?

  20. #20
    I love Love LOVE NADOTA!!
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Posts
    30,460

    Re: Thoughts on Mafia #2/#3

    Alright na_no ur aimed first

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •